Do Spoilers Count as News Coverage?
I’m going to get this out of the way right off the bat: I’ve been watching this season of Celebrity Apprentice. I know, it’s lame and I’m not very proud of it. But it was worth outing myself to talk about MSNBC’s lame attempt at covering “Entertainment News.”
First, when I read the entertainment section of a website I expect to read about who died, who OD’d or who’s sleeping with whom. I don’t, under any circumstances, want to be reading spoilers about your own network’s TV shows. I mean, really?
Think about it this way – if I care even the slightest bit about a television program, I either watched it when it aired or I’ve DVR’d it. If I’ve watched it, then I obviously don’t need your play by play of what happened. If I’ve DVR’d it and you spilled the beans on the show, well, now you’ve just pissed me off. That’s exactly what happened this morning with the Apprentice. I woke to the headline of “*** Gets the Boot on Apprentice.” Notice how I blanked out the name? That’s because, unlike MSNBC, I care enough about my readers to not spoil TV shows for you.
Now, I realize that some of you are saying “but Scott, if you DVR’d the show NBC doesn’t really care if you watch it later or not since you’ll forward through the commercials and that’s all they really care about.” Ahhh yes, good point astute reader, but if you’ve ever watched an episode of the Apprentice you know that each episode is basically a commercial in and of itself. Trump and Mark Burnett have been geniuses in integrating brands into the challenges and tasks on the show for years. So while, yes, I may skip the commercials, what about the company that ponied up big bucks for a giant two-hour spot? Ask Kodak, Lifelock or Norton if they’d be pissed about that.
And let’s be clear here, it’s not just Apprentice using integrated sponsorship in programs. Show likes FX’s “Damages” and Fox’s “24″ have been using American car brands front and center for years. Like it or not, this is the new reality of television advertising and when you print spoilers hours after a show airs, you’re screwing the pooch on your ad sales.
Finally, let’s talk about my real beef with all of this “coverage.” It’s lazy, lazy lazy. How can you watch a TV show on your own network, write a four paragraph rundown of the episode (complete with spoilers) and call yourself a journalist? Where’s the analysis of why *** was fired? Where’s the gripping piece about the rise and fall in ratings of The Apprentice? Why did NBC decide to make this season’s Apprentice run a two-hour weekly program instead of the usual one hour? Journalism should be about covering a real event – politics, sports, human interest etc – not shortening the transcript of a show into four paragraphs.
I don’t know what’s more lame – the fact that I actually watch the Apprentice or that MSNBC thinks that this even remotely qualifies as insightful news.



Twitter




4 Comments, Comment or Ping
Brian
Great points. I’m watching too…the only one in my house…
anyway, this is one of those shows that I “fill in the gaps” with….But I agree, spoilage in a headline is just annoying…for any show!
This is why I still watch my “top tier” shows usually the night they air when we can….just to avoid this type of thing…
Now back to the Celebrity Apprentice. I usually watch ALL my shows on DVR simply because of the commercials, but I can’t imagine watching a full two hours of CA in “real time”…it would be so agonizing with all the breaks…
It’s much easier to FF and cut the 2 hours down to a manageable time frame!
Apr 5th, 2010
Scott
With any product it’s all about hitting the target demographic. I would bet that the most desirable 18-40 yr old demo mostly has a DVR of some sort. That means that television execs need to understand and sell around this new reality. CA, Damages, 24 and others have found clever ways to do that within the show. Why are their own writers working against them by writing spoilers thereby all but guaranteeing I won’t watch this most recent episode?
Puzzling.
-S
Apr 5th, 2010
Brian
I think 30 Rock does the best job of it.
They sort of mock the product placements they decide to do.
You know you still want to watch! The train wrecks are too much to ignore.
Apr 5th, 2010
alice
I al so watch the Apprentice, and I usually watch it around Tuesday night.
I HATE spoilers.
When Lost is on in the US, me being in México, I turn off Twitter because some people just can’t stop themselves and that kind of pisses me off.
Yahoo news spoiled for me the winner of Top Chef I think 2 seasons back. I was saving it to watch it over the weekend with more time to savor the finale and I was totally spoiled
So now, whenever a season finale is coming up I simply don’t read my news feed. A drag, but I prefer it to their “reporting”.
Also I agree with you, I believe it is great that we can now decide when we watch our tv shows. I think it has somewhat hurt the water cooler gossiping about “last night’s show” because people no longer watch them at the same time. However, I far better prefer to decide if I want to watch it when it first airs, or, for example, wait the whole season and watch 13 hours over a weekend. My choice.
Apr 5th, 2010
Reply to “Do Spoilers Count as News Coverage?”